Why did the Titanic tour submarine implode?

Thanks JEH,
Sadly, as most of us suspected...
 
Thanks JEH,
Sadly, as most of us suspected...

At least 2 things are recognized...
1) The US/USCG doesn't have and needs a unified way to handle small submersible regulations (even though Ocean Gate didn't comply with applicable existing federal and state law/regulations.)
2) The US/USGC doesn't have and needs a unified operational search, rescue, and recovery team/plan for subsea operations (even though the US Navy founded the DSSP after the loss of the USS THRESHER, that has been allow to wither.)

Edit: changed "deep submergence" to "subsea operations" to align with the report.
 
Well. Not much to say. The report is comprehensive and even more disgusting than we’ve discussed here.
The vessel was stored outside.

The acoustics increased then stopped, then increased again and the CEO disregarded the ‘tell’.

And the Coast Guard also owned their lack of oversight.

All the other basic stuff like manufacturing defects we all witnessed also gets mentioned.

The investigator did a good job, if anyone is asking me.
 
Final USCG Report is released.
A trial with evidence against, so to say. Very interesting(surprising) to find in this report quasi all that has been already presented to the public. The whole history of the company and the fortunes of test models, to highlight the "toxic" behaviour of the founder. Some conclusions saying everything and nothing in particular like :
6.1.1.5. TITAN’s carbon fiber hull design and construction in terms of winding,
curing, gluing, thickness of hull and manufacturing standards introduced flaws
that weakened its original structural integrity, and those flaws likely worsened
over time.


Important Safety recommendations that I try to resume here :

upload_2025-8-6_16-13-14.png


In the end, one big take away, different formulas - choose whichever suits you

⚠️ Bold & Concerned
  • "Wait—You’re Diving Without Certification?!"

  • "No Cert? No Chance."

  • "Uncertified and Underwater: What Could Go Wrong?"

  • "Depths of Denial: The Perils of Skipping Certification"
Sarcastic or Ironic
  • "It's Just a Stamp... Until Something Implodes"

  • "Who Needs Certification Anyway? Just Your Life."

  • "Paperwork Won’t Save You... But Certification Might"
Reflective & Urgent
  • "Certification: More Than a Checkbox—It’s a Lifeline"

  • "Beyond the Seal: Why Certification Isn’t Optional"

  • "Safety Isn’t Optional—Neither Is Certification"
 
Now several years on. This is the best dispassionate analysis I've seen on OCEANGATE TITAN to date. It discusses physics, materials, classification, regulation, and decisions before and after the accident. The only quibble I have is the implosion animation... but I have seen real video of real small item implosion so...<shrug>.

 
Great video, well presented.

I think the real basic problem was the choice of carbon fiber for the hull.
Great material in tension,..not so good in compression.
 
If there is any argument, the manner in which carbon fiber is used is not currently as good as titanium for underwater vessels. The idea the original titanium spheres can still go to the bottom versus a structure with a likely mtbf schedule is significant and not to be ignored.
 
Which titanium spheres do you refer to? I don't know what their life cycles are.
 
I don't agree that CFC is an inferior material for anything.

It can only be used incorrectly.

Use in submersibles requires a little more thought.
 
Which titanium spheres do you refer to? I don't know what their life cycles are.
The original dive vessels that went to the Titanic in ?1976? are still in service and have been recertified to dive to 6300 per the video. So life cycle in years > 50, I don’t know the dive cycles..
 
I don't agree that CFC is an inferior material for anything.

It can only be used incorrectly.

Use in submersibles requires a little more thought.
It doesn’t matter whether you agree. The facts say otherwise for diving to the bottom of the sea.

Perhaps your english 2nd language is affecting you. But certainly cfc is an inferior product for many things in engineering.

And it can be used properly or improperly.

Third point is for certain, but we probably at this juncture in innovation can agree cf has failed in use as a submersible.
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top