New Aftmast Rig

"The bottom line is that the jib can act as a slat for the mainsail, in which case a small jib makes sense [and] The mainsail can act as a slotted flap for the jib, in which case a large jib makes sense [a big jib: a Genoa]"

(Tom Speer)

Indeed

It is well known that the sail area of a two-sail (2 Sails) sailboat can be distributed in many ways

What does that have to do with a new "Atrocia" with three sails (3 Sails) two of which are completely overlapped?

You keep quoting Tom Speer—at great length (in cruisersforum)—and it is clear that you do not understand what you are quoting
 
Screenshot_2026-10-23-22-06-05-04.webp



"MastFoil"

It is the solution to your problem:

how to make the rig of a large, ocean-crossing catamaran—sailing downwind—more manageable, while avoiding the challenges of handling a massive mainsail.
 
What does that have to do with a new "Atrocia" with three sails (3 Sails) two of which are completely overlapped?
I'm disappointed that you seem to be referring to my aftmast rig as a new 3-sailed Atrocia.
You mentioned this failure in posting #22 back on page 2

Can you name specifically the items that made Atrocia a failure?.....other than the quoted unsuccessful distribution of sail areas between the mainsail and the headsail?? Please list them one by one.
 
AERODYNAMICS OF OVERLAPPED STAYSAILS


I'm working out the sail suite for a Class 40 under construction, and am wrestling with a problem that seems to bother no one but me.

The problem is that it's common for racers to use multiple headsails in such a way that the leech of the A-sail extends further aft than the leech of the aft-most headsail -- thereby ruining the various 'slot effect' benefits of the inner sails. It doesn't seem sensible aerodynamically.

Since reading Gentry, my (amateur) understanding is that the leech of the trailing sail must extend further aft than the leech of the leading sail, or else the singular foil is compromised. A staysail that is 'buried' by the leech a big A-sail might help a bit with mainsail flow attachment... or might reduce the drag of the mast... but is more likely to simply add drag itself or to generally interfere (particularly if its twist cannot be controlled to match that of the A-sail and main, which is usually the case in the low clew jibs and genoas used on most racers).

Staysails that are 'overlapped' by A-sails don't add upwash, lift, etc.


But no one seems to pay attention to this. Very smart people are violating it everywhere -- on Maxis, VORs, Class 40s...

Unknown.png

Unknown-1.png

Unknown-2.png

Unknown-3.png

With a Class 40 on a TWA broad reach, it's typical to furl the Solent so as to not blanket the A-sail, and to sail with the overlapping A-sail and 'buried' staysail as in the above photo. But this can't be right.

What we should see instead is a large staysail with perhaps a fairly high clew so the foot and LP can be extra long, extending beyond the leech of the A-sail and overlapping the main quite a bit. Or so I think.

But so far, I'm only getting blank stares and shrugs from designers. Conventional practice ignores the issue. I just can't figure out why I'm wrong.

Thoughts and/or recommended resources very much appreciated.
Many more interesting postings on this subject thread !
 
Can you name specifically the items that made Atrocia a failure?.....other than the quoted unsuccessful distribution of sail areas between the mainsail and the headsail?? Please list them one by one.
You're the one who promotes the sort of rig that almost all racers dumped long ago - why do others have to tell you why they don’t work well? However;

1- The mast had to be heavier than usual because it didn’t have distributed loads from a normal mainsail to support it.
2- The jib needed heavier cloth than a normal light weather jib and had a boom, so it was heavy and clumsy.
3- The idea behind the rig was basically a rating “optimisation”; spinnaker size was limited by the foretriangle size so moving more sail to the foretriangle created a bigger spinnaker.

Once the big-jib small-main rig was dumped and a normal one fitted, the boat went much faster and was top scoring boat in the trials for the Seawanhaka Cup. So the hull was good, the crew was great, the rig was a failure that was replaced by a fractional one - just as in modern sailing.
 
Atrocia's Problems

1- The mast had to be heavier than usual because it didn’t have distributed loads from a normal mainsail to support it.
2- The jib needed heavier cloth than a normal light weather jib and had a boom, so it was heavy and clumsy.
1) The mast needed to be heavier as it did not utilize modern day lower spreaders, nor diamonds.
I guess that the mast is so thick and heavy because of missing lower shrouds , four ; back and forward,
or alternatively diamond stays.
A thinner, lighter mast without lower shrouds will not stay in column, in a seastate it will pump.
On the upper shown 6mR forward lower shrouds would collide with the jib-boom.
A big mainsail , together with backstay and running backstay can more or less take over the function of lower shrouds (see flexible rigg on starboat , " invented" by Pimm von Hütschler ; world champion 1937)
A small , not top mainsail can't take over lower shrouds' tasks.

2) That jib was described as a terrible heavy cloth of old days that could not hang properly in many winds, particularly light winds. On top of that it had a VERY sharp leading edge that was reported as extremely difficult to trim (point) properly in upwind conditions

Excessive Weight Aloft
The mast designed for Atrocia was over-engineered and immensely heavy. In the 6-meter racing class—where design rules dictate incredibly tight tolerances—this high weight aloft proved catastrophic. It actively reduced the boat's righting moment, making it unstable and inefficient compared to its competitors.

Missing the "Slot Effect" Intentions
The rig was conceptually built around optimization concepts that were simply not well-understood in the 1920s. Its original club-footed jib setup performed horribly in light, early-season wind conditions, preventing it from generating standard sailing drive.

Delayed Delivery and Lack of Preparation
Adding to its mechanical flaws, the boat was delivered late to its owners. The crew had insufficient time to trial the hull, iron out its severe idiosyncrasies, or tune the radical rig before major competitions. [1]

Mast Sectional Shape
Furthermore, likely that mast section was NOT of a more aerodynamic shape that we get with modern materials, but probably a rectangular section characteristic of wooden mast of that era.

I thing this article was correct,..
 
Last edited:
IMG20261026150734.webp


half a lifetime trapped in a corner of page 109 of CA Marchaj "Sail Performance"
 
View attachment 210805


"MastFoil"

It is the solution to your problem:

how to make the rig of a large, ocean-crossing catamaran—sailing downwind—more manageable, while avoiding the challenges of handling a massive mainsail.

Here is an interesting problem I just discovered with this design.

Originally Posted by DougR View Post

The more important problem developed later when the boat lost a mast while sitting in its slip at our yacht club. Because of the rotating foil design, the mast is supported at the bottom and top only, with no rigging support anywhere else. One day a moderate squall blew thru and the wind velocity was just right to start the front mast pumping a bit, which quickly developed into a harmonic and it caused the mast to buckle in the middle and collapse forward over the front beam. Of course this caused a good bit of concern in the Chris White organization. The exact same thing happened a second time later when the boat was on the hard for winter storage.

I believe the “fix” for the failures was beefing up the section of the mast for stiffness and perhaps also shortening the mast a bit in future production. As I understand it, the same failure also occurred on at least one other vessel.

That's interesting, I was out of the multihull business when these boats were introduced, so never boarded one for a more complete inspection.

EDITED; Several other vessels experienced this mast problem as I understand it.

I really appreciated Chris White's attempt to produce a more user friendly design for the cruising folks, which this vessel represented.

I think my single-masted-ketch would be considerable cheaper to get to the same sort of results,..without those TWO somewhat complicated mast, and TWO booms of the Mastfoil system.
 
Screenshot_2026-10-26-16-43-13-39.webp

(Fossati, Milan Wind Tunel)

Aft Mast with 2 interacting sails

really, it’s not that difficult

one sail, 1
two sails, 2
three sails, 3

Screenshot_2026-10-26-16-47-32-44.webp
 
Screenshot_2026-10-23-22-06-05-04.webp


Big Catamaran

2 Sails
2 MastFoil

The problem of handling the massive, mansion-like catamaran downwind has been solved.
 
What I don’t understand about these endless discussions regarding rigs and sails is:

1) Why it isn’t clearly stated whether the conversation concerns sailing upwind, reaching, or sailing downwind—three entirely different worlds. And when discussing upwind sailing, why isn’t it specified whether the wind speed is 10–12 knots or 25–27 knots, nor what angle of attack is being considered

2) Why are massive yachts lumped together with small dinghies or 1–3 ton sailboats? On this forum, you read things as absurd as: - I have no trouble reefing the mainsail on my 3.5-ton yacht, so you shouldn't have any trouble reefing the gigantic mainsail on your 50–60-foot catamaran

3) Why, when arguing about functionality, comfort, and safety of a cruising yacht with small crew, do people get bogged down in aerodynamic minutiae. What’s next—drilling holes in the mast (which, like the keel and rudder, is sacred) to hide the halyards from the wind, Oh, wait
 
Basically in this subject thread I am dealing with Multihull Cruising boats in the 35 to 75 foot size. My wish with the aftmast design was to get rid of those tall full battened mainsails that can contribute greatly to capsize potentials in gusty conditions,...and that are harder for the older cruising sailor to raise, lower and reef.

Lets see if there are alternatives , some of which we are exploring. I've presented my lower aspect ratio, 3 smaller sail version, all roller furling.

And being a true sailor I want mine to go to windward with some reasonable success. Doing my sailing years I often sought out monohulls I could challenge to windward duals, and I surprised a lot of those guys. A major trick was to slow down and go just a little faster than them. Then the challenge became to just barely sail up to windward of them !! It was FUN.

I realize there are many naysayers that my aftmast rig will not outpoint them, And in many cases that may prove to be true. But if I can get close in a CRUISING design, it will be worth it. Reaching and running much more simple.

EDITED: Attaining that windward capability was a big reason I spent so much time studying what those knowledgeable aerodynamist had to say.
 
Atrocia's Problems


1) The mast needed to be heavier as it did not utilize modern day lower spreaders, nor diamonds.
I guess that the mast is so thick and heavy because of missing lower shrouds , four ; back and forward,
or alternatively diamond stays.
A thinner, lighter mast without lower shrouds will not stay in column, in a seastate it will pump.
On the upper shown 6mR forward lower shrouds would collide with the jib-boom.
A big mainsail , together with backstay and running backstay can more or less take over the function of lower shrouds (see flexible rigg on starboat , " invented" by Pimm von Hütschler ; world champion 1937)
A small , not top mainsail can't take over lower shrouds' tasks.

2) That jib was described as a terrible heavy cloth of old days that could not hang properly in many winds, particularly light winds. On top of that it had a VERY sharp leading edge that was reported as extremely difficult to trim (point) properly in upwind conditions

Excessive Weight Aloft
The mast designed for Atrocia was over-engineered and immensely heavy. In the 6-meter racing class—where design rules dictate incredibly tight tolerances—this high weight aloft proved catastrophic. It actively reduced the boat's righting moment, making it unstable and inefficient compared to its competitors.

Missing the "Slot Effect" Intentions
The rig was conceptually built around optimization concepts that were simply not well-understood in the 1920s. Its original club-footed jib setup performed horribly in light, early-season wind conditions, preventing it from generating standard sailing drive.

Delayed Delivery and Lack of Preparation
Adding to its mechanical flaws, the boat was delivered late to its owners. The crew had insufficient time to trial the hull, iron out its severe idiosyncrasies, or tune the radical rig before major competitions. [1]

Mast Sectional Shape
Furthermore, likely that mast section was NOT of a more aerodynamic shape that we get with modern materials, but probably a rectangular section characteristic of wooden mast of that era.

I thing this article was correct,..

That article clearly just follows the same source I used - Hoyt’s autobiograpy.

However, if you think that article’s correct then how do you explain its claim that the Six Metre class "design rules dictate incredibly tight tolerances”? Six Metres ranged from boats like Hoyt’s Sheila at just 27’4” LOA or Giles’ Jonquil with a displacement of 3 tons, up to LOAs of over 38 feet and displacement over 4 tons (Circe, etc). Differences of 25-30 percent are hardly “incredibly tight tolerances”.
 
EDITED: Attaining that windward capability was a big reason I spent so much time studying what those knowledgeable aerodynamist had to say.

So why do you ignore what Tom Speer said about a conventional sloop’s mast providing driving force?

Why did you insult Mikko Brummer’s CFD by calling it “BS”?
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top