Atrocia's Problems
1) The mast needed to be heavier as it did not utilize modern day lower spreaders, nor diamonds.
I guess that the mast is so thick and heavy because of missing lower shrouds , four ; back and forward,
or alternatively diamond stays.
A thinner, lighter mast without lower shrouds will not stay in column, in a seastate it will pump.
On the upper shown 6mR forward lower shrouds would collide with the jib-boom.
A big mainsail , together with backstay and running backstay can more or less take over the function of lower shrouds (see flexible rigg on starboat , " invented" by Pimm von Hütschler ; world champion 1937)
A small , not top mainsail can't take over lower shrouds' tasks.
2) That jib was described as a terrible heavy cloth of old days that could not hang properly in many winds, particularly light winds. On top of that it had a VERY sharp leading edge that was reported as extremely difficult to trim (point) properly in upwind conditions
Excessive Weight Aloft
The mast designed for
Atrocia was over-engineered and immensely heavy. In the 6-meter racing class—where design rules dictate incredibly tight tolerances—this high weight aloft proved catastrophic. It actively
reduced the boat's righting moment, making it unstable and inefficient compared to its competitors.
Missing the "Slot Effect" Intentions
The rig was conceptually built around optimization concepts that were simply not well-understood in the 1920s. Its original club-footed jib setup performed horribly in light, early-season wind conditions, preventing it from generating standard sailing drive.
Delayed Delivery and Lack of Preparation
Adding to its mechanical flaws, the boat was delivered late to its owners. The crew had insufficient time to trial the hull, iron out its severe idiosyncrasies, or tune the radical rig before major competitions. [
1]
Mast Sectional Shape
Furthermore, likely that mast section was NOT of a more aerodynamic shape that we get with modern materials, but probably a rectangular section characteristic of wooden mast of that era.
I thing this article was correct,..
Atrocia – a study of experimentation, risk and failure Figure 1 - US 35 Atrocia (c) Mystic Seaport, Rosenfeld Collection, #2...
6metre.blogspot.com