New Aftmast Rig

CarlosK2
PLEASE STAY OUT OF ANY SUBJECT THREAD SUBJECTS I AM PARTICIPATING IN !!!!!!!!
Most of your postings are worthless to the topic.
 
Brian, while I understand the theoretical efficiency of the headsail due to its cleaner leading edge, I'm still puzzled....
CT249

The theoretical effectiveness of the headsail is not due to its cleaner leading edge. It's due to its interaction with the mainsail. The mainsail gives a boost to the head sail, and the headsail reduces the lift of the mainsail. It's exactly the same as lee-bowing your competitor - the jib gets a lift from the main, and the main gets a header from the jib. But the effectiveness of the whole combination is increased, so there's a net gain.

The thin leading edge of the headsail is actually a disadvantage because there's no forward-facing area upon which leading edge suction can act. A mast with no separation zones would be a better leading edge than the thin leading edge of the jib - hence the effectiveness of wingmasts and pocket luffs.

There are two separated zones behind the mast - one on the lee side and one on the windward side. The jib reduces the effect of the leeward surface separated zone in a couple of ways. One is by reducing the wind speed at the mast, so the mast effectively sails in a lighter wind, producing less drag. The other way is by creating a favorable pressure gradient to the jib trailing edge that encourages the separated flow to reattach to the mainsail.

In high winds when the mainsail is operating at a lower angle of attack, the backwinding of the main by the jib, causing reverse curvature in the luff of the main, also reduces the windward separation zone. This is anagous to under-rotation of a wingmast.

So the jib reduces the drag of the mast over what you'd have with the same rig bare headed. This is in addition to the lee-bow effect.

Tom Speer
 
Notice what TSpeer says,...contributes to the drive of the whole sail rig.
He did NOT say contributes to the forward drive of the mast itself !!
...only Mikko hinted at that very small amount.

Mikko's observations about the individual contributors was obtained with recent CFD studies,...computer wizardry that he admits in other postings can be questionable, particularly on his computer which he was having problems with at the time

I wish TSpeer was still on the forums, and might clear up this question.

PS: Even if there was someway to could find a way to contribute some very small driving force to the mast section itself,.. I'll bet the drag force of that same mast section would far offset the drive amount.

Imagine driving down the road while holding a mast section out the window, Does anyone think that they could reduce the drag of unit to zero, or even a negative,....REGARDLESS of the multitude of orientations you might try out.

I AM noting what Tom wrote. He wrote that he “agreed completely” with Mikko’s statement that "the mast is not just a drag-device but contributes significantly to the driving force of the sails…..the mast drive (is) 1,2 kgf (that's in the positive, forward direction for the mast as well. “ Look at the actual words - Tom “agree(d) completely” with Mikka’s study that showed that the mast drove “in the positive forward direction”.

The CFD study obviously included the drag of the mast and all other parts of the rig.

Your example of sticking a mast out of a window shows nothing. A model yacht rig used in the same ways also produces drag that you can feel even when the sails are at the correct angle of attack - but sails drive boats.

It’s weird that you apparently don’t know that sails cause aero drag.
 
CarlosK2
PLEASE STAY OUT OF ANY SUBJECT THREAD SUBJECTS I AM PARTICIPATING IN !!!!!!!!
Most of your postings are worthless to the topic.

So are you going to keep out of spamming Cruiser Forum threads as you have been asked to?
 
from an older posting on Sail Aerodynamics
Subject: Sail Aerodynamics, Sail Wake
_________________________________________________________________
Tom Speer wrote in the steamboat multihulls forum:

> Taking a second look at it
> <http://www.ship.saic.com/pictures/acup-flow.jpg>
I'm not sure what's shown on the back plane. Whatever is shown on that plane is probably different from what's shown on the sail - and I may have been mistaken in what I said earlier. You can see the boundary layer in the wind at the water surface.
It can't be static pressure, because static pressure would be essentially
constant from the water up, away from the boat . I don't think the colors
show the velocity magnitude because there are high velocities near the
trailing vortices, so the velocity should increase, then drop off at the very
center. Dynamic pressure drops off to zero at the water surface and there's a
total pressure deficit in the core of the trailing vortices, so dynamic
pressure is a possibility. So total pressure would be a good guess.

> The component of the velocity in the true wind direction is another
> possibility.
>
> The caption on the FANS page mentions pressure, so the sail colors could be showing static pressure. If that's the case, then there may be no
correspondence between the colors on the sail and the colors on the back
plane. And my remarks about the flow in the slot being slower than
> freestream could not be justified by the evidence in the picture.
______________
Brian responded:
Just in case there is some confusion over the still photo verses the movie I
would refer the viewer to either:
<http://www.ship.saic.com/overview_fans.html> and click on movie
<http://www.ship.saic.com/pictures/aone_small.mov>

What I am finding in my review of some of this computational methods of
investigating sail forces and flow analysis (CFA, CFD, vortex lattice models,
etc) is that generally there are so many assumptions made upfront in order to
simplify the equations so the computer can solve them, that the results get
skewed quite a bit from reality, ie, a quote from one of the annalist;


"CFD = Computer Fluid Dynamics. CFD is a great tool for visualizing and
explaining flow phenomena. While the latest flow software is very powerful and capable of calculating amazing things at astonishing accuracy, the old saying "garbage in, garbage out" is more true than ever. Besides of presenting the problem in a meaningful way, one needs lots of knowledge and experience to interpret the results correctly. Simulation through CFD is especially useful at giving qualitative information - when it comes to quantitative results or hard numbers, you have to be even more cautious when drawing conclusions about the merits of one design over another. Wind tunnel tests are needed to calibrate and validate the CFD code before reliable results are obtained."

"With the power of modern CFD at the desktop, it is too easy to produce
beautiful pictures with little connection to reality
. Often these pictures are
produced by flow experts with little sail-specific knowledge, and then
interpreted by sail designers without sufficient understanding of the CFD
tool, and as a result you get just that - pretty pictures."


Brian continues:
And take a look at the LACK of a trailing vortex off of the upper tip of the
mainsail....I don't think this is reality.

I also find interesting the totally screwed-up flow lines on the portion of
the mainsail above the hounds....certainly makes one question the
effectiveness of this sail area, AND the negative effect the vortices off of
the fractional jib have on the mainsail's upper portion. I believe both Tom &
I have questioned the fractional rig verses mast head rig subject in previous
discussions.
________________________________________________________________
Tom Speer continues:

> However, I think the important point is the huge vortex coming off the boom. It shows that the sail rig does not act like a a wing with double the
geometric aspect ratio of the sail rig due to surface effects, and the
> optimum planform is not a semi-ellipse. The vortex is also strongly
> affecting the region of the mainsail where the chord is the greatest.
> People usually concentrate on the vortex at the top, but the vortex at the
foot may be more significant. It's worth considering how to shape the
> mainsail so as to reduce the strength of the vortex and to move some of the sail area away from its influence. One answer is to use a wishbone boom and round the clew so the planform of the whole sail rig looks more like a
sail-board rig.
______________________
Brian replied:
This is just example where the analogy between an aircraft wing and a sail rig
differs quite a bit, "it shows that the sail rig does not act like a wing with
double the geometric aspect ratio...." And this is another example of where
theory and reality differ, particularly when trying to analyze sail rigs with
aircraft wing technologies. I intend to point out some other examples soon,
and raise them for comment.

Per Tom's observation about the boom end of the rig, and substituting a
'sailboard' type bottom, I not so sure that the aerodynamic gain could be
traded for the neccessity to 'shape' the conventional mainsail (vangs,
outhaul, etc) to operate properly with the non-parallel, sometimes fractional
headsail.

Pardon my plug for my unconventional mast-aft design
<Sail Propulsion - Revisiting a Mast-Aft Sailing Rig http://www.runningtideyachts.com/sail/>
one might note that the flows off of the bottom of my 'mainstaysail' (and my
headsail as well) should not create as much negative vortex action in this
region. And note, I did utilize a wishbone boom on my mizzen sail to
accomplish what Tom has suggested as an optional boom arrangement for the
conventional mainsail.
 
Last edited:
IMG_20260815_143922.webp


"Atrocia with an unsuccessfull distribution of sail area between the mainsail and headsail" (CA Marchaj)

Discussing the atrocious yacht "Atrocia" in 2026 makes absolutely no sense, and, to top it off with two headsails that completely overlap! And that forward-raked mast, OMG

If you’re concerned about the large mainsails found on big catamarans, well, take a look at this solution:


IMG_20261023_133803.webp
 
On another forum Catsketcher just posted this observation, I like Chris White designs but the performance claims are not correct.
At Sailing Anarchy a member named Agility had a Mast Foil.

(underlined portions by me, Brian)

Interesting post. I’ve actually owned a Chris White Atlantic 57, a Chris White Atlantic 47 mast foil, and now own a Balance 526, so I’ll add a perspective from someone who lived with both approaches.

First, I agree the Atlantic mast foil concept is fundamentally optimizing for something different.

Performance-wise, my mast foil boat was slower than a traditionally rigged performance cruising cat with big mains and larger headsails. Period. They also don’t carry daggerboards, so they simply won’t point as high. None of that surprised me and I don’t think Chris was trying to win that comparison.

But what I think gets understated is just how dramatically easier a mast foil boat is to sail.

On passages, I don’t recall waking my wife up once in probably 75+ nights underway because of sail handling. In fact, I don’t really remember either of us waking the other for sail changes at all. My wife is not especially interested in sail trim or managing sail plans, and the boat simply didn’t demand it.

No reefing drills. No “all hands on deck.” No urgent sail transitions because of a squall line. The response time was measured in seconds, not minutes. Going from 20 to 60Kt winds (happened twice) required three reefs, all done without a foulies and accomplished in less that 30 seconds singlehanded. Of course we were headed down wind.

Now compare that with my Balance 526—which I love—and they are completely different philosophies. The Balance is unquestionably more rewarding to sail hard and is materially faster than the Atlantic 47. But it also asks more of the crew. Bigger mains, larger foresails, more active sail management, more decisions and more exhausting.

For some people that involvement is the whole point.

For others—especially couples cruising long distances who prefer to sail with the winds—the Atlantic mast foil idea deserves more credit than it gets because reducing workload has real value.

One additional thought: if I could buy an Atlantic 57 of a newer vintage and price as my Balance 526, the Atlantic would win for me hands down. Not because it is faster—it is—but because for short-handed sailing it is a superior platform. It lets you sail more, with less effort, and with less disruption to life aboard. First thing we bought on the Balance were marriage savor radios and we use them all the time.

I still think Chris White was solving a different problem than Outremer, Balance, or HH. Whether that tradeoff is worth it depends entirely on how you actually sail.
 
Farr Yacht Design President chooses a catamaran for his personal boat


I see where he grew up in Annapolis. I wonder if he was wondering around when I was involved in the multihull business up there for quite a number of years, and imported the first FP cat Louisiane 37 to the Annapolis Boat Show late 1980's.

Sure would like to talk with this gentleman Patrick Shaughnessy about his subsequent catamaran experiences?
 
Stiletto 23 Experiment?

This might make for a very interesting experiment,..and much cheaper than building a new vessel.
Take one of these very hi-perf Stiletto 23 and place a version of my aftmast on it.


This is a sketch of the new framing structure I had suggested as a possibility in such an experiment,..
1792837035606.webp


I'm thinking the original hulls are usable, and the mast tube cut down in height,...maybe even the original crossbeam with addition reinforcements???

That mast base placement beam/plate structure would have to be moved forward in keeping with my latest decrease in fwd mast rake, and the aft crossbeam would need additional reinforcement to carry the 'dual backstays'
 
Last edited:
Sails in Combination

...I thought it might be interesting to revisit this portion of Paul Bogataj's paper

SAILS IN COMBINATION
Each sail by itself is much simpler than the combination of a foresail and mainsail as in the sloop rig. The sails are operating so close to each other that they both have significant interaction with the other. The most interesting feature of this is that the two sails together produce more force to pull the boat than the sum of their forces if they were each alone.

Earlier, upwash was identified as the increase in flow angle immediately upstream of a wing. There is also a corresponding change in angle, called downwash, just behind a wing, where the flow leaving the wing has been turned to an angle lower than the original flow. This is the cause of the well known “bad-air” that a boat just to windward and behind another boat experiences.

The mainsail of a sloop rig operates in the downwash of the forward sail, causing the flow angle approaching the mainsail to be significantly reduced from what it would be otherwise. This decreases the amount of force that the mainsail produces. The observed affect commonly referred to as “backwinding” is partially a result of downwash from the foresail, but is also due to the higher pressure on the windward side of the genoa being very close to the forward, leeward side of the mainsail, causing the flexible material of the mainsail to move away from that higher pressure.

The foresail of a sloop rig operates in the upwash of the mainsail. The wind as far upstream as the luff of a genoa is influenced by the upwash created by the mainsail. Hence, a jib or genoa in front of a mainsail has a higher flow angle than it otherwise would have by itself, causing an increase in the amount of force that the forward sail produces. So, while the mainsail is experiencing detrimental interference from the foresail, the foresail benefits from the interference of the mainsail. Notice that more air is directed around the curved leeward side of the foresail. This causes higher velocity (lower pressure) and more force. The net result is that the total force of the two-sail system is increased, with the foresail gaining more than the mainsail loses.

There is a converse affect to a windward boat receiving “bad air” (downwash) from a boat ahead and to leeward. A leeward boat gains additional upwash (“good-air”?) from a boat just to windward and slightly behind that acts like a lifting windshift until it moves ahead of the windward boat. This is the same phenomenon from which a foresail of a sloop rig benefits.

Another consequence of the difference in flow angles that the two sails experience in each others’ presence is that the mainsail must be trimmed to a much closer angle with the boat’s centerline than the foresail, which is able to be trimmed to a lead position well outboard. This angle represents the difference in upwash on the foresail and downwash on the mainsail due to each other.

MASTHEAD RIG.
On a masthead rig, where the forestay is attached to the top of the mast and both sails taper to basically zero chord length at their heads in a similar fashion, the interference effects of the sails on each other are similar along the entire height of the mast. The mainsail ends up being rather tightly trimmed all the way up becauseof the genoa’s downwash, and the genoa gains from favorable upwash all the way up.

FRACTIONAL RIG.
A fractional rig has the more complicated characteristic that the top of foresail is not as high as the top of the mainsail. This means that the top of the foresail is very close to the front of the mainsail at a height where there is still an ample amount of chord length in the mainsail. As the foresail luff approaches the mainsail luff, the upwash on the foresail due to the mainsail increases, because the low pressure behind the mainsail has more affect the closer the flow gets to it. This causes the top of the foresail to experience even more upwash and contributes to a fractional rig’s foresail being trimmed more twisted than a masthead rig’s foresail.

The top of the main on a fractional rig extends well above the foresail, leaving the upper portion of the mainsail free to experience the apparent wind without the downwash interference of the foresail. Apparent wind toward the top of the mast comes from a much higher angle, so the mainsail above the foresail experiences much higher wind angles than the lower portion of the mainsail where the genoa is causing substantial downwash. This change in flow angle with height on a mainsail is quite dramatic with a fractional rig and leads to trimming a fractional rig’s mainsail with more twist than a masthead rig’s mainsail

...and a couple of flow sketches (please excuse their older rough nature)

Attached Files:

1793373906661.webp

RunningTideYachts.com
 
Last edited:
Change,....That mizzen sail has now been attached to the mast tube in order to reduce a 'bare mast' drag situation.
1792936019200.webp


1792936416050.webp
 
The points I was trying to make for my aft-mast rig with its big genoa is that I was trying to meet a big variety of conditions with a limited sail inventory (my 3 sails are the only ones I have onboard, and are set up to be reduced in size by roller furling, not hoisted or replaced by alternatives).

As such I wanted a good size genoa sail for those often encounter 5-15 knot winds that we would really like to sail in rather than turning on the engine(s). This size sail, in those conditions, should be relatively easy to handle, ...(and when out cruising I would NOT be looking at getting into tacking duals). I was seeking to get the best from this genoa sail by giving it the best help from the 'cutter jib' (mainstaysail as I refer to it), and providing for its best dumping traits as described by Tom Speer.

I'm also quite convinced that modern sail materials such as the tape-drives or these Titanium sails would allow for a very light weight sail that would maintain their shape even in higher wind conditions. These materials should also allow for sailing under a partially furled sail. As I have said before I believe a hefty size ROUND furling 'tube' (headstay) should utilized to negate some difficulties of stalling the sail due to a 'too-sharp' leading edge to the headsails. Combine this type of headstay foil with a modern 'shaped foam insert' in the leading edge, and this sail should set pretty well in the roller-reefed condition. It would be nice to be able to utilize this reef-able genoa up to the 30 knot range.
 
Tom Speer posted this long ago on Steamradio,...an early multihull forum,...

As Brian has pointed out, the reason the slot does not work entirely like a
conventional venturi is because the mass of air flowing through the slot is
not constant as you change the gap. As you close the slot less mass flows
through it and more mass flows around the sail with the dividing streamline
(separating the air that goes to leeward from that which passes to windward)
moving to windward.

The finest explanation I've seen of the slot effect was given by A.M.O.
Smith in his 1975 Wright Brothers Lecture ("High Lift Aerodynamics," AIAA
Journal of Aircraft, Vol. 12, No. 6, June, 1975, pp 501-530). This should
be available from any university engineering library.

Smith starts out by considering what limits the amount of lift a section can
provide and shows that there are two basic factors: when the local pressure
reaches Mo^2*Cp = -1 [Mo is the freestream Mach number and Cp is the local
pressure coefficient], and when the boundary layer separates. The first
criterion places an absolute limit on the lift that can be produced
regardless of the type of high lift device.

The second, the load-carrying capacity of the boundary layer, is what sets
the limit in nearly all practical cases. For attached flow, the velocity at
the trailing edge is a little slower than, and the pressure a little higher
than for the freestream conditions. Somewhere ahead of the trailing edge
the local velocity is higher and the pressure is lower. So the last thing
the boundary layer has to do as it gets to the trailing edge is to negotiate
a region of increasing pressure and decelerating flow. If the increase in
pressure is too much the slower flow in the boundary layer literally gets
backed up. This is what causes separation - you have flow moving forward
meeting flow being pushed backwards, both get brought to a stop at some
point, and the only direction they can both go is away from the surface. So
there's a limit to how suddenly the flow can be decelerated.

The harder you can decelerate the flow, the longer you can maintain the
higher velocity on the lee side and the more lift you can produce. It's
just like coming up to a stop sign - you can either coast into it from a
long way out, or you can come zooming in and slam on the brakes at the last
minute. It turns out that the velocity profile for maximum deceleration of
the flow has a concave shape - a steep drop at the beginning when the
boundary layer is fresh, and a pronounced flattening out of the profile with
distance from the start of the drop (kind of like a car whose brakes fade
badly). If the maximum velocity is very high, the deceleration has to start
much earlier and more of the airfoil's lee side has to be devoted to it. If
the deceleration is started later, then the maximum velocity can't be as
high, but the high speed/low pressure can extend over more of the surface
and less of the surface has to be spent on the deceleration. Naturally,
there's an optimum combination of the two which results in milking as much
lift out of the lee side as you can get at a given Reynolds number. This is
important for the interplay between main and jib. But put that aside for
the moment and consider slot effect.

Here's what Smith says about slot effect:

"A remark about the action of slots comes from a recent NASA report: 'It is
well recognized that the usual function of the slot is that of a
boundary-layer control device permitting highly adverse upper surface
pressure gradients to be sustained without incurring severe separation.
This stabilizing influence results from the injection of the high energy
slot flow into the upper surface boundary layer.' A still more recent NASA
report states, 'This leading-edge slat gives the fluid which passes through
the gap between the slat and the main airfoil a high velocity.
Consequently, a boundary layer which grows on the upper surface of the main
airfoil has more momentum than it would have in the absence of the slat.'

"There are two things wrong with these statements. First of all, the slat
does not give the air in the slot high velocity. If anything, it gives the
air low velocity. Secondly, the air through the slot cannot really be
called high-energy air. All the air outside the actual boundary layers has
the same total head. Properly designed and spaced slats are far enough
apart that each component develops its own boundary layer under the
influence of the main stream, and there is no merging within the slot.
Topologically, the process of boundary-layer development is no different
from that on a biplane. Subject to their particular pressure distributions,
the two boundary layers on a biplane grow, trail off downstream, diffuse,
and finally merge. That is just the process for an airfoil system of two or
more elements so long as merging does not occur within the slot.

"The next paragraphs will elaborate on and confirm what we have just said.
There appear to be five primary effects of gaps, and here we speak of
properly designed aerodynamic slots.
"1) Slat effect - in the vicinity of the leading edge of a downstream
element, the velocities due to circulation on a forward element, for
example, a slat, run counter to the velocities on the downstream element and
so reduce pressure peaks on the downstream element.
"2) Circulation effect - in turn, the downstream element causes the trailing
edge of the adjacent upstream element to be in a region of high velocity
that is inclined to the mean line at the rear of the forward element. Such
flow inclination induces considerably greater circulation on the forward
element.
"3) Dumping effect - because the trailing edge of a forward element is in a
region of velocity appreciably higher than freestream, the boundary layer
"dumps" at a high velocity. The higher discharge velocity relieves the
pressure rise impressed on the boundary layer, thus alleviating separation
problems or permitting increased lift.
"4) Off-the-surface pressure recovery - the boundary layer from forward
elements is dumped at velocities appreciably higher than freestream. The
final deceleration to freestream velocity is done in an efficient manner.
The deceleration of the wake occurs out of contact with a wall. Such a
method is more effective than the best possible deceleration in contact with
a wall.
"5) Fresh boundary-layer effect - each new element starts out with a fresh
boundary layer at its leading edge. Thin boundary layers can withstand
stronger adverse gradients than thick ones."

Smith then goes on to discuss each one of the effects in more detail. The
fresh boundary layer effect is typically the only one people mention. The
dumping and circulation effects are responsible for the observation that a
jib is more effective per area than a main. The slat effect is important in
dealing with the flow around the mast.

Just because the circulation effect causes the jib to produce more lift on a
per area basis does not necessarily mean that the entire system would be
more effective if the jib were made larger than the main. The jib and main
can play different roles and the relative importance of each of the five
factors above are different for each.

For example, consider a genoa with significant overlap. At the location of
the genoa trailing edge, the flow around the main, in the absence of the
jib, is substantially parallel to the trailing edge of the genoa. This
means the circulation effect is not as important. The circulation effect
can be likened to an increase in the angle of attack, because the presence
of the downstream element and the angle of attack both increase the
component of the flow normal to the trailing edge. This requires a larger
circulation around the jib in order to balance the conditions there,
resulting in more lift on the jib. With the large overlap, there's not much
lateral component applied to the genoa's leech.

But the dumping velocity effect is very important. The main doesn't produce
the sharp leading edge pressure peak of a thin airfoil because the peak is
blunted by separation behind the mast. So putting the trailing edge of the
genoa back where the highest velocity occurs maximizes the velocity at the
trailing edge of the genoa. Since the trailing edge velocity is higher, the
jib can carry a higher velocity farther aft on the lee side than it would
otherwise. To go back to the braking metaphor, it's like the genoa's
boundary layer only has to slow down for a yellow light, but not come to a
full stop, so the braking can start later.

For a non-overlapping jib, the situation is different. The mast and main
cause a considerable lateral component at the trailing edge of the jib,
enhancing the circulation effect. The dumping velocity is still important
for the non-overlapping jib, too.

Now sailboats have to operate at a wide range of Reynolds numbers. To get a
rough idea of the Reynolds number, take the wind speed in knots, multiply by
the chord in feet, and multiply that by 10,000. So a 5 ft chord in a 5 kt
wind is operating at a Reynolds number on the order of 250,000. At that
Reynolds number, it takes a long ways for the flow to slow down to the
sub-freestream velocity at the leech of the main. A laminar boundary layer
can't do it at all in the length of the chord - so laminar separation will
definitely occur, hopefully with reattachment to form a laminar separation
bubble and turbulent boundary layer (most likely just behind the mast).

But the point is, pretty much the entire lee side of the main is fully
engaged in decelerating the flow in light wind/low Reynolds number
conditions. The shorter the main, the lower the maximum velocity on it can
be. That means a lower dumping velocity for the jib, too, so more of the
pressure recovery has to be done on the jib, which cuts into its lift
production. Is it better to have a short highly-loaded jib with high
dumping velocity and large main with a long pressure recovery and more
off-surface jib pressure recovery? Or is it better to have a large jib,
with less loading and lower dumping velocity, and a shorter main to finish
up the job? It's not a slam-dunk decision either way.

I've not tried to design main/jib combinations, but I have looked at rigid
wing/slotted flap configurations. The data are on my web site. I
considered flap sizes from 20% of the total chord to 50% of the total chord.
Especially in the light wind conditions, the bigger flap (hence bigger main)
was more effective. The 50/50 combination only starts to get into the
genoa/main range, and I didn't look at anything like a slat/wing combo which
would be more representative of a jib/main. But the trend did not point to
a larger forward element being the better choice.

I would love to be able to look at this issue with the proper tools.
Unfortunately, the only programs I have for multiple elements can't handle
separation, so they can't predict maximum lift or the onset of the drag rise
due to stall. I had to do some really crude fudging to guess at stall
effects. It would take something like MSES to calculate the two-dimensional
flow around main and jib (with boundary layer), and that program is out of
my price range. I've asked Drela about a multiple-element XFOIL, and he's
thought about it but hasn't pursued it.

The bottom line is that the jib can act as a slat for the main, in which
case a small jib makes sense. The main can act as a slotted flap for the
jib, in which case a large jib makes sense. Deciding between these two
extremes is a quantitative issue that can be answered with experience on the
water, wind tunnel test, or computational methods. Each has its strengths
and drawbacks.

Cheers,

Tom Speer
 
Overlap Genoa Size on my Aftmast Rig

Somewhat surprisingly I never did bother to calculate the overlap % of my genoa on the aftmast rig I proposed. I just did it by dropping a straight line down from the masthead in my drawing, then measuring that "J' dimension, then divided that length into the luff perpendicular (LP),....standard method.

Guess what I came up with?.....slightly less than 104%.
Surprised even me, as I had just guesstimated it at 110-115% for years.
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top