from an older posting on Sail Aerodynamics
Subject: Sail Aerodynamics, Sail Wake
_________________________________________________________________
Tom Speer wrote in the steamboat multihulls forum:
> Taking a second look at it
> <
http://www.ship.saic.com/pictures/acup-flow.jpg>
I'm not sure what's shown on the back plane. Whatever is shown on that plane is probably different from what's shown on the sail - and I may have been mistaken in what I said earlier. You can see the boundary layer in the wind at the water surface.
It can't be static pressure, because static pressure would be essentially
constant from the water up, away from the boat . I don't think the colors
show the velocity magnitude because there are high velocities near the
trailing vortices, so the velocity should increase, then drop off at the very
center. Dynamic pressure drops off to zero at the water surface and there's a
total pressure deficit in the core of the trailing vortices, so dynamic
pressure is a possibility. So total pressure would be a good guess.
> The component of the velocity in the true wind direction is another
> possibility.
>
> The caption on the FANS page mentions pressure, so the sail colors could be showing static pressure. If that's the case, then there may be no
correspondence between the colors on the sail and the colors on the back
plane. And my remarks about the flow in the slot being slower than
> freestream could not be justified by the evidence in the picture.
______________
Brian responded:
Just in case there is some confusion over the still photo verses the movie I
would refer the viewer to either:
<
http://www.ship.saic.com/overview_fans.html> and click on movie
<
http://www.ship.saic.com/pictures/aone_small.mov>
What I am finding in my review of some of this computational methods of
investigating sail forces and flow analysis (CFA, CFD, vortex lattice models,
etc) is that generally there are so many assumptions made upfront in order to
simplify the equations so the computer can solve them, that the results get
skewed quite a bit from reality, ie, a quote from one of the annalist;
"CFD = Computer Fluid Dynamics. CFD is a great tool for visualizing and
explaining flow phenomena. While the latest flow software is very powerful and capable of calculating amazing things at astonishing accuracy, the old saying "garbage in, garbage out" is more true than ever. Besides of presenting the problem in a meaningful way, one needs lots of knowledge and experience to interpret the results correctly. Simulation through CFD is especially useful at giving qualitative information - when it comes to quantitative results or hard numbers, you have to be even more cautious when drawing conclusions about the merits of one design over another. Wind tunnel tests are needed to calibrate and validate the CFD code before reliable results are obtained."
"With the power of modern CFD at the desktop, it is too easy to produce
beautiful pictures with little connection to reality. Often these pictures are
produced by flow experts with little sail-specific knowledge, and then
interpreted by sail designers
without sufficient understanding of the CFD
tool, and as a result you get just that - pretty pictures."
Brian continues:
And take a look at the LACK of a trailing vortex off of the upper tip of the
mainsail....I don't think this is reality.
I also find interesting the totally screwed-up flow lines on the portion of
the mainsail above the hounds....certainly makes one question the
effectiveness of this sail area, AND the negative effect the vortices off of
the fractional jib have on the mainsail's upper portion. I believe both Tom &
I have questioned the fractional rig verses mast head rig subject in previous
discussions.
________________________________________________________________
Tom Speer continues:
> However, I think the important point is the huge vortex coming off the boom. It shows that the sail rig does not act like a a wing with double the
geometric aspect ratio of the sail rig due to surface effects, and the
> optimum planform is not a semi-ellipse. The vortex is also strongly
> affecting the region of the mainsail where the chord is the greatest.
> People usually concentrate on the vortex at the top, but the vortex at the
foot may be more significant. It's worth considering how to shape the
> mainsail so as to reduce the strength of the vortex and to move some of the sail area away from its influence. One answer is to use a wishbone boom and round the clew so the planform of the whole sail rig looks more like a
sail-board rig.
______________________
Brian replied:
This is just example where the analogy between an aircraft wing and a sail rig
differs quite a bit, "it shows that the sail rig does not act like a wing with
double the geometric aspect ratio...." And this is another example of where
theory and reality differ, particularly when trying to analyze sail rigs with
aircraft wing technologies. I intend to point out some other examples soon,
and raise them for comment.
Per Tom's observation about the boom end of the rig, and substituting a
'sailboard' type bottom, I not so sure that the aerodynamic gain could be
traded for the neccessity to 'shape' the conventional mainsail (vangs,
outhaul, etc) to operate properly with the non-parallel, sometimes fractional
headsail.
Pardon my plug for my unconventional mast-aft design
<
Sail Propulsion - Revisiting a Mast-Aft Sailing Rig http://www.runningtideyachts.com/sail/>
one might note that the flows off of the bottom of my 'mainstaysail' (and my
headsail as well) should not create as much negative vortex action in this
region. And note, I did utilize a wishbone boom on my mizzen sail to
accomplish what Tom has suggested as an optional boom arrangement for the
conventional mainsail.