ancient kayaker
aka Terry Haines
- Joined
- Aug 6, 2006
- Posts
- 3,497
- Reaction score
- 147
- Location
- Alliston, Ontario, Canada
Terry,
I'm assuming, then, that you have read the entire thread to this point and still have some questions that have not already been totally mashed into the ground?
Yep. The first few pages had posts with substantive arguments and after that it became repetitive, personal or just plain quibbling. I skimmed through every single one of the other posts and read completely any that seemed to offer something new to the argument.
This question cannot be resolved by repetitive opinions, calculations based on assumed values, artists’ impressions of sail lift vectors pointing in arbitrary directions and photos of boats with their bows pointing to the heavens at the moment the photo was taken. If this was something being proposed for the first time I would invoke the rights conferred by my honorary Missouri citizenship*.
There is a considerable weight of opinion but it falls on both sides of the argument and feathers outweigh opinion that is not accompanied by data or observation. So I gave MHO of where we were at and asked if an observation could be made, proposing a method. Of course an on-board data logging system with load cells would be the thing to use and probably exists on Volvo boats, l’Hydroptere and boats of that ilk, but they are unlikely to release their data for all to see.
Don’t take this personally, any of you. Just pointing out that none of this could be admitted into court. I’m not saying anyone is wrong and least of all do I claim Doug is right. Come to think of it, he just asked the question...
* “show me” for the non-US folk ...