TollyWally
Senior Member
- Joined
- Mar 19, 2005
- Posts
- 774
- Reaction score
- 26
- Location
- Fox Island
It's been a long time since I've been on this site. Always an enjoyable and informative time. Recent increases in the price of fuel have reestablished my interest in Atkins box keel design work. A very informative thread boatdesign.net/forums/showthread.php?t=16066 ( I hope I did that right) was very enlightening.
I have an old book at home, a first edition by Atkin that my old man bought as a young man, that I have recently been rereading. Much of the interest buzzing over the internet has to do with some of the seemingly extraordinary claims of fuel economy. I'm not formally trained as a naval architect but I apprenticed as a shipwright as a young man and spent 15 years fishing, I know my way around a boat, LOL. In any event this is not about me.
Reading Atkin's book closely I'm struck by three details.
1. He consistantly placed these boats in a performance envelope from 10 - 20 mph. Being content to achieve moderate speed.
2. He was very particular in specifying particular motors, shaft speed,
and propellers.
3. The design of the keel was refined over the years, he indicated that was in the interest of cleaning up the flow of water to the propeller.
To me this indicates a concentration upon the art of matching propeller requirements to motor torque curves.
Recent recreations of his designs or designs inspired by him have had varying success regarding fuel economy, some impressive others not so much.
What I am wondering about is whether a good measure of the rather extraordinary economy claims may stem from superb choices matching propellers, gears, and motors.
I know you guys have already had some good discussions regarding box keels but if you're not all sick of it by now I'm interested in other's opinions and ideas.
TollyWally
I have an old book at home, a first edition by Atkin that my old man bought as a young man, that I have recently been rereading. Much of the interest buzzing over the internet has to do with some of the seemingly extraordinary claims of fuel economy. I'm not formally trained as a naval architect but I apprenticed as a shipwright as a young man and spent 15 years fishing, I know my way around a boat, LOL. In any event this is not about me.
Reading Atkin's book closely I'm struck by three details.
1. He consistantly placed these boats in a performance envelope from 10 - 20 mph. Being content to achieve moderate speed.
2. He was very particular in specifying particular motors, shaft speed,
and propellers.
3. The design of the keel was refined over the years, he indicated that was in the interest of cleaning up the flow of water to the propeller.
To me this indicates a concentration upon the art of matching propeller requirements to motor torque curves.
Recent recreations of his designs or designs inspired by him have had varying success regarding fuel economy, some impressive others not so much.
What I am wondering about is whether a good measure of the rather extraordinary economy claims may stem from superb choices matching propellers, gears, and motors.
I know you guys have already had some good discussions regarding box keels but if you're not all sick of it by now I'm interested in other's opinions and ideas.
TollyWally