In the process of choosing a rig for my future cat. Would like to get some input from engineers and owners.
The cat is a 10.5m, demountable, with a central pod. Initially I was keen on a 3 stay rig like Pic #3. I need a safe rig with the sail area broken down into manageable areas and loads. The 3 stay rig was presented to me be an experienced multihull sailor and it seems the right fit for my needs. But I am wondering about the structural benefits of an A-frame mast instead of a single mast. My main concern is the compression in the middle of the forebeam, the added weight and rigging (dolphin striker) needed to take that compression. I want as simple rigging as possible and it looks like the A frame has benefits in that area. I will not discuss efficiency here, except option #1 vs option #2. The cat is light and carries sufficient sail area to be fast anyway. I am not looking for the most efficient rig, obviously. I want the easiest rig possible, and would even take the weight penalty of the A frame if it is easy to sail.
I'm looking for professional and non professional opinions regarding the complete weight of the rig and it's weight influence of the rest of the platform. I am aware of the fact that the A-frame itself is heavier, but I'm more interested on the overall weight of the entire system and it's simplicity. I believe weight savings are possible with the A-frame on the rest of the structure, lack of side stays etc, furthermore, the A frame would allow me to put instrumentation on its connecting spars. An added short mast for a radar an windmill needs to be taken into consideration on the global weight for a single mast. I will most probably not use furlers, or maybe only on the foresails.
So I'm after rigging simplicity, multifunction and curious about global weight of the rigs (all rigging, loads influencing the rest of the platform, auxiliaries like windmill or radar mast).
If you look at the A-frame rig with the twin forestay option #1, it can't get any simpler than that. In any case spars will be carbon, and it is worth mentioning that the central pod might carry quite some weight (people+heatpump+outboard+anchor+chain). I strongly dislike dolphin strikers because of its point loads. There might be an option #4 with single mast and twin forestays. Total SA is around 55-60sqm with a 12m long mast.
So, what is your take on it ?
The cat is a 10.5m, demountable, with a central pod. Initially I was keen on a 3 stay rig like Pic #3. I need a safe rig with the sail area broken down into manageable areas and loads. The 3 stay rig was presented to me be an experienced multihull sailor and it seems the right fit for my needs. But I am wondering about the structural benefits of an A-frame mast instead of a single mast. My main concern is the compression in the middle of the forebeam, the added weight and rigging (dolphin striker) needed to take that compression. I want as simple rigging as possible and it looks like the A frame has benefits in that area. I will not discuss efficiency here, except option #1 vs option #2. The cat is light and carries sufficient sail area to be fast anyway. I am not looking for the most efficient rig, obviously. I want the easiest rig possible, and would even take the weight penalty of the A frame if it is easy to sail.
I'm looking for professional and non professional opinions regarding the complete weight of the rig and it's weight influence of the rest of the platform. I am aware of the fact that the A-frame itself is heavier, but I'm more interested on the overall weight of the entire system and it's simplicity. I believe weight savings are possible with the A-frame on the rest of the structure, lack of side stays etc, furthermore, the A frame would allow me to put instrumentation on its connecting spars. An added short mast for a radar an windmill needs to be taken into consideration on the global weight for a single mast. I will most probably not use furlers, or maybe only on the foresails.
So I'm after rigging simplicity, multifunction and curious about global weight of the rigs (all rigging, loads influencing the rest of the platform, auxiliaries like windmill or radar mast).
If you look at the A-frame rig with the twin forestay option #1, it can't get any simpler than that. In any case spars will be carbon, and it is worth mentioning that the central pod might carry quite some weight (people+heatpump+outboard+anchor+chain). I strongly dislike dolphin strikers because of its point loads. There might be an option #4 with single mast and twin forestays. Total SA is around 55-60sqm with a 12m long mast.
So, what is your take on it ?