24' Well net boats for aquatic research - need designer recommendation

John Riddle

Junior Member
Joined
Aug 19, 2008
Posts
37
Reaction score
10
Location
Charleston, SC
I am working with a research team to replace their existing 22' well net boats patterned after the Tremblay mullet skiff (similar to the Florida skiff in the photo). The outboard motor is mounted in the forward 1/3 of the hull in a well that opens to a tunnel to the transom. The purpose is to have a large, unobstructed work surface with a very shallow draft for working close to the beach and marsh.

The team would like to make several modifications based on their experience with the existing design and I believe those modifications warrant a designer's input. I would like to connect with any interested designer or to receive recommendations to a designer for me to contact.

Thank you!
 

Attachments

  • FLA WELL BOAT.webp
    FLA WELL BOAT.webp
    215.5 KB · Views: 99
The team would like to make several modifications based on their experience with the existing design and I believe those modifications warrant a designer's input.

Do they want to modify the existing boat, or modify the design, and then build a new boat?

What sort of modifications are they thinking of doing?

You noted that the 22' well net boat is similar to the Florida skiff in the photo posted - do you have any photos of the well net boats?

If you provide some more details here, then the boat designers on this Forum might be able to offer advice directly via the forum.
 
The design modifications will be applied to the new boats built with glass-sheathed plywood and epoxy.
The most potentially significant modifications they are considering are:
  • Adding 2' to the LOA
  • Modifying the flat bow entry to reduce pounding
  • Installing a helm station in the extreme bow
  • Widening the tunnel from the current 24" to 30" or more
I am not seeking design recommendations via posts in this forum but rather the name and contact info of a working designer with the ability to apply these elements in a successful design configuration. I don't know if one exists but I prefer not to wing it without consulting.
 
I’m not familiar with any designers that would be able to assist.

I would offer two of your ideas are in conflict to some degree. You want a finer entry, but you want a more forward helm and your center of mass is forward as desired by engine placement and these things mean the boat will tend to pound. A good designer will be able to assess the current boat and advise changes and discuss the inherent conflicts in your wishes. It is possible/likely the current boat does not have sufficient deadrise at the transom or that the bow is simply up too high for’d, etc.

Make sure to do a bit of a start from scratch approach and establish a new SOR.

Good luck.
 
As Fallguy has noted, some things seem to be in conflict - it sounds like you want to have the helm station forward of the engine as shown on the existing boat photo.
This will require more buoyancy in the bow to support the weight, which seems to be a bit in conflict with the desire for a finer entry?
 
There is no doubt that an engine positioned so far forward will shift the CoG toward the bow, but it is equally true that the fishing gear and crew located aft will more than offset that tendency. Not to mention the stern—which is less full than usual—shifting the CoB forward. In short, talking about "bow-diving" or anything of the sort makes no sense. Boat design is about balancing conflicting requirements so that, while no single need is perfectly met, the overall result is the best possible compromise.
I see no indication that the OP wants a "finer bow." The bow should be as fine as the vessel's requirements dictate, regardless of the engine's forward position.
Let the experts speak with the OP and his experienced colleagues. I don't think anyone can currently speculate on the merits or flaws of a hull when no one knows the SOR.
 
  • Modifying the flat bow entry to reduce pounding
  • Installing a helm station in the extreme bow
That will probably result in a bow down trim. It adds weight forward and reduces buoyancy.
 
Let us not confuse terms, please. The buoyancy of a hull—or a section of it—does not depend on its weight, but solely on its shape (assuming "buoyancy" refers to the upward force the hull generates). According to this physical principle, weight at the bow does not reduce the vessel's buoyancy at the bow. Reserve buoyancy—that is, how much further the boat can submerge without sinking (however that "how much" is measured)—does, however, depend on the weight of the structure, the cargo, and the equipment on board.
 
One other friendly comment and not meant to be more. The aft section of the hull looks very flat. These types of skiffs with a flat aft section (perhaps desired for shallow work) are very commonly known to pound. We have a well known design here on the Gulf Coast called a Stoner skiff. And it has this notable quality.

These boats are well known for the large work area. Of course, the engine placement is not the same, but the hull shape is….the Stoner has a fairly fine entry, but if you look close; it flattens out quickly versus offering any deadrise whatsoever.
IMG_0306.webp
 
I agree with fallguy, but given that the work area must be different, that the control station is forward—and requires greater protection—and that the weight distribution is completely different, the boat's hull forms will not be similar or even alike.
My comment is that the two hull forms of the Stoner and the well net boat, from the available views and information we have appear to be very similar. And the Stoner is known to pound in the Laguna Madre which typically gets a 1 foot chop in windy conditions.

The point I make is that the hull form for an improved boat may need to be changed, if possible, to soften the ride some.

As you mentioned, @TANSL, there may be conflicts.

This is why I recommend a completely new SOR, so the buyer gets to choose across conflicts. Perhaps they can run a cat styled boat even, for example.

To reduce polemics, this is my last post on the thread.
 
@fallguy, there is no polemics here, as I believe you are right about much of what you say. I fully agree that the vessel's SOR will determine its hull form. Therefore, even though the boats might appear similar, they will likely differ significantly below the waterline—"similar" does not necessarily mean they are alike.
Given that the weight of the crew working aft, the fishing gear, and the catch itself are all concentrated at the stern, I do not believe a catamaran hull would be advisable. However, this is all just speculation; until the final SOR is known and potential users have been consulted, it is premature to discuss the appropriate hull forms for this project.
You have your opinion, and I have mine. There is no controversy; we each have our reasons—some of which may be mistaken, and others... well, mistaken too.
 
Last edited:
This article is from 1989, but still pretty well describes the Mullet skiffs seen today.
They are VERY specifically designed for one job, so conventional wisdom goes out the window when building one.
It’s all about the function of the deck, carrying a ton or more of nets, and having the ability to deploy and retrieve them quickly by hand in very shallow water.
The trip to and from the grounds is very much a secondary consideration, other than it needs to happen fast.
getting wet and pounding are part of the job.
The high console in the extreme end of the bow helps the fishermen spot their quarry and maintain a commanding view when deploying the gear.
 
This article is from 1989, but still pretty well describes the Mullet skiffs seen today.
They are VERY specifically designed for one job, so conventional wisdom goes out the window when building one.
It’s all about the function of the deck, carrying a ton or more of nets, and having the ability to deploy and retrieve them quickly by hand in very shallow water.
The trip to and from the grounds is very much a secondary consideration, other than it needs to happen fast.
getting wet and pounding are part of the job.
The high console in the extreme end of the bow helps the fishermen spot their quarry and maintain a commanding view when deploying the gear.

My impression is that the boat is not so much "designed" as it is the result of simply building it as fast and cheaply as possible. It's kind of elegant in a way. The result does what it was meant to do and that was good enough for thousands of hulls over the years.
 
Forum posts represent the experience, opinion, and view of individual users. Boat Design Net does not necessarily endorse nor share the view of each individual post.
When making any potentially dangerous or financial decision, always employ and consult appropriate professionals. Your circumstances or experience may be different.

  • Back
    Top